Chapter 658

Yes.

From that moment on.

Her heart for him.

Had probably already died.

So it didn't matter whether he knew or not.

Given his understanding of her.

If she had truly forgiven him.

She would have buried her face in his chest and wept.

Pouring out all her pain to him.

But she didn't.

She bore all the pain alone.

Completely shutting him out of the ordeal.

From then on.

She had sentenced him to death in her heart.

Yet he clearly still had a chance to make amends.

Before the pain had intensified to its extreme.

"You were all deceived by her."

"Why didn't you tell me?"

"Even a small hint would have been enough."

"Then I wouldn't have done such cruel things to her."

Liam Sullivan's voice.

Was filled with the agony of utter remorse.

Sophia Miller, who had been suffering all along.

Finally couldn't hold back any longer.

Her heart trembled.

Wiping her tears as she shouted.

"Liam Sullivan!"

"Why must we be the ones to tell you these things?"

"Couldn't you have observed carefully yourself?"

"If you were truly so worried about Vivian."

"Couldn't you have noticed her distress?"

"You're usually so sharp."

"How could you possibly not have noticed anything was wrong?"

"It's just that your heart was always with that temptress, Luna Clark."

"So Vivian's pain and her changes."

"You completely overlooked them."

"You only cared about that temptress."

"Isn't that right?"

On the day of Vivian's gala dinner.

She had been by her side the entire time.

The events of that night.

Vivian's suffering.

She understood it better than anyone.

When Oliver Winston and Ethan Roscente went to find Liam.

They hadn't experienced that night's events firsthand.

Only she had witnessed the tragedy unfold.

Feeling Vivian's bone-deep pain as if it were her own.

She had originally thought.

After Vivian had endured so much pain.

Liam would be good to her.

Help her move past the pain.

Bring her complete happiness.

Ensure she wouldn't suffer any more harm.

The miscarriage might indeed affect their relationship.

So even someone as outspoken as herself.

Had kept her mouth tightly shut.

Not daring to reveal it.

But things didn't develop in the ideal direction.

Liam showed great concern for that Luna Clark.

His entire focus was on her.

He neglected Vivian.

And today, for that woman's sake.

He pushed Vivian down.

Injuring her so severely.

Even with her usually good temper.

She couldn't control her anger and sorrow.

Seeing Vivian in such a miserable state now.

She felt a deep dislike for Liam.

His actions.

Perhaps were unintentional.

Not meant to truly hurt.

Yet they wounded Vivian to her very core.

"Because of you, Vivian."

"Nearly died during the miscarriage."

"And now you pushed her."

"Wah..."

"How can you be so heartless?"

"Hurting her so badly."

"Her body is already so weak."

"It simply can't withstand such injuries."

"Do you want her to die?"

The more Sophia spoke, the more upset she became.

Her words grew increasingly unrestrained.

Ethan Roscente quickly pulled her back.

Hissing a warning in a low voice.

"Stop talking."

"Have you lost your mind?"

Once this woman got worked up.

She was beyond reason.

Besides, Liam was already suffering enough.

No need to add insult to injury.

Sophia pushed him away resentfully.

"Let go of me."

"Why won't you let me speak?"

"I'm not saying anything wrong."

"You men are all no good."

"Always talking about love."

"But the deepest wounds."

"Are always inflicted by you."

Remembering that Vivian had been hurt by Liam twice.

She couldn't help but shed tears of sorrow.

Her voice choked with sobs.

"Why must women endure so much pain?"

"Is your men's love."

"So hurtful?"

"Do you have to torment a woman half to death."

"Before you regret it?"

"If love is truly like this."

"We'd rather not have it."

Liam closed his eyes.

Listening to Sophia's scolding.

He didn't feel embarrassed at all.

Instead, he felt he deserved it.

Sophia's words made sense.

Why should he rely on others to tell him.

Before he knew she had gone through such things?

Was he truly so thoughtless?

Vivian hiding the miscarriage.

Was originally a test for him.

If he had cared for her with meticulous attention.

And discovered the harm she had suffered.

Then there might have been room for redemption.

She would have felt he still cared for her, trusted her, understood her pain.

But because of the matter with Luna Clark.

His mind was entangled in the love and hate of a past relationship.

He had no mind to care for her.

Let alone notice anything amiss.